I just read Sean Goedecke's blog post The just-say-no engineer was a ZIRP phenomenon, and he expresses a lot of the same observations I've had about the software industry of the last few years.
The just-say-no engineer is obsessed with quality, is happy to move slowly, and blocks code changes by default.
That's more or less a description of the personal brand I had built as a software engineer throughout my career. I wrote a blog post myself in 2018 about how every software organization needs designated "buzzkills" that balance out unrestrained optimism.
And, boy, is it a tough time for us right now. The software industry is fully in its YOLO phase in the last few years. Any governor on code going from written-to-shipped is out of style.
The just-say-no engineer is having a hard time in the era of AI. It used to be that they only had to say no to more junior engineers’ handwritten PRs, but now they have to say no to a barrage of AI-generated code... For the first time in their careers, they’re under a lot of pressure to lower their standards and start saying yes.
The thing that Sean brings up that I never thought much about was how flimsy the explanation of GenAI has been for this shift in the industry. He argues that it had more to do with ZIRP (zero interest rate policy) ending, which coincidentally happened around the same time.
When banks hiked interest rates, almost every tech company immediately laid off 5-20% of their engineers.
...
Fortunately, the end of ZIRP coincided roughly with the rise of ChatGPT, so tech companies were able to to blame their layoffs on the power of AI. Saying “with this transformative new technology, we’re able to deliver 10x the value with half the engineers” is a much stronger message, even though it doesn’t make much sense (if this is true, why not keep your engineers and deliver 20x the value?)
The vibe shift may have less to do with GenAI and more to do with shipping fast as the only priority in an environment without free money.
If LLMs had not taken off this decade, we would still be seeing the same cultural shifts in the industry. Companies would still be laying off engineers, and the engineers whose job has been to say no to things would still be upset and confused about why they’re now being punished for saying no.
Sean is certainly not an economist, so I take this explanation with a grain of salt, but it's an interesting angle I hadn't considered before. The industry has gotten very weird in the last few years, and I'm still trying to figure out how to care about quality when it's suddenly out of fashion.







